Contra-expertise in a crypto dispute: when a second opinion counts
Author: Simcha Schrijver
In short
Counter-expertise in a crypto dispute is an independent second review of an existing crypto report. A second expert checks whether the conclusions really follow from the blockchain data. That can undermine the report, but it can just as well confirm it. Either way, you know better where you stand.
Paucitas is an independent expert firm in the Netherlands that prepares expert reports for legal proceedings, with more than ten years of experience from Simcha Schrijver. Paucitas tests the facts and the method and leaves the legal judgment to the court.
Get in touch with Paucitas or ring +31 20 244 5774. In a free intake we discuss the report and what a second review could deliver.
In a nutshell
Doubts about a crypto report, or is the other side using one against you? Paucitas reviews the report independently and tells you honestly what holds up and what does not.
A crypto report is on the table and the outcome does not feel right. Perhaps the other side is using it against you, perhaps you have doubts about the conclusions yourself. That is unsettling, especially when a lot is at stake.
In this blog you will read what counter-expertise in a crypto dispute is, when it makes sense and how Paucitas goes about it.

What is counter-expertise in a crypto dispute?
Counter-expertise is an independent review of an existing investigation report. In a crypto dispute, a second expert looks at the transactions, assumptions and conclusions of the first report. The aim is not to force a different outcome at any cost, but to establish whether the findings really follow from the data.
A second opinion is different from a new investigation from scratch. Paucitas starts from the existing crypto investigation report and checks whether the steps can be followed, whether the method is sound and whether it contains assumptions the data does not support.
When does counter-expertise make sense? 3 moments
Not every report needs a second review. But there are three moments when it often makes a difference:
- The other side relies on a report. If it goes against you, it is wise to have the conclusions tested.
- You have doubts about your own report. Even a report that looks favourable can have weak spots. Better to know them in advance than to see them exposed at a hearing.
- A lot is at stake. With a large financial interest or proceedings with serious consequences, a second review gives peace of mind and a firmer footing.
Does one of these sound familiar? Let Paucitas take a look with you. You can ring at any time, 24/7, on +31 20 244 5774.
How does a counter-expertise work?
Paucitas starts with the existing report and the underlying data. We read the question the report set out to answer, look at which transactions and addresses were used and re-run the analysis ourselves on the blockchain. Where needed, we also go through the underlying documents, emails and other communication, so that a complete picture emerges, with a timeline and the route of the money, step by step. Does the route hold, are the amounts and times correct, and do the conclusions match what can actually be seen?
Paucitas does all tracing itself, without tracing tools. Where the first report makes an assumption the data does not support, we say so. Where it is right, we say that just as clearly. Sometimes the first report turns out stronger than expected, sometimes weaker.
An example from practice
In a civil case, the other side submitted a report stating that a disputed transfer had ended up with the client. The client's solicitor had doubts about one step in the reasoning.
Paucitas re-traced the route. Most of the report held up, but at one intermediate step an assumption had been made that the data did not support. With that evidence, the solicitor could focus the argument on that point. A fuller case is in case study: counter-expertise on a crypto report.
Paucitas takes privacy very seriously and never shares clients' personal details. This is a composite example: names, amounts and details have been changed. The situation is one we see in practice.
Testing facts, not passing judgment
Paucitas establishes what can technically be seen on the blockchain. Whether those facts amount in law to a loan, a gift or something else is for the court and the lawyers. Paucitas does not write towards a desired outcome, and that is exactly what makes the report useful. In England and Wales, the rules on expert evidence are in Civil Procedure Rules Part 35.
What is in a counter-expertise report?
- The question addressed and the report that was reviewed.
- A factual account of the relevant transactions, with dates, amounts and addresses.
- For each conclusion: endorse, qualify or rebut, with reasons.
- The limits of the investigation: what is established and what is not.
Anyone can follow and understand the report step by step, even without a technical background.
In which cases does counter-expertise come up?
In a civil dispute it may concern a contested transfer or who controlled a wallet. In a criminal case, the origin or destination of funds. In a tax matter, asset verification and the origin of assets. Each time the question is the same: do the facts stand up as the first report presents them? More on proceedings is in expert report for the court and requesting a second opinion on a crypto report.
Who provides counter-expertise in a crypto dispute?
Paucitas. We work independently of the party that produced the first report and sell nothing but investigation. You can come to us together with your solicitor. We provide the factual evidence; the advocacy stays with your legal team. More on our approach is in counter-expertise and second opinion.
- Costs: every investigation is tailored. You receive a bespoke quote in advance, which we go through together, so there are no surprises.
- Turnaround: from the same day to around two weeks.
- Contact: you can ring at any time, 24/7. We answer the form within 1 to 3 hours, and email within 24 hours, usually the same day.
Want to know whether a report stands up? Get in touch for a no-obligation introduction, or ring +31 20 244 5774.
Source: Civil Procedure Rules, Part 35: experts and assessors.
Do you have questions about this blog?
Feel free to get in touch with Paucitas. Paucitas can be reached by phone 24/7, including evenings and weekends. Through the contact form we usually reply within 1 to 3 hours, and we answer e-mail within 24 hours.
Contact form
Usually a reply within 1 to 3 hours
"*" indicates required fields
We only use your details to contact you about your request. You can read more about this in our privacy statement.
More short answers
Paucitas also answers frequently asked questions about crypto investigation briefly and clearly in the knowledge base.
More on Paucitas
Frequently asked questions about counter-expertise in a crypto dispute
What is the difference between counter-expertise and a new investigation?
Paucitas explains: counter-expertise starts from an existing report and tests the assumptions, method and conclusions. A new investigation starts from scratch. That gives you targeted certainty about the report already on the table.
Can counter-expertise also confirm a report?
Paucitas can do that too. If the first report holds up, Paucitas says so clearly. That is valuable too, because you then know where you stand.
The other side is using a crypto report against me. What now?
Paucitas advises having it tested independently. Paucitas checks whether the conclusions hold or go further than the data allows. Then discuss the outcome with your solicitor.
Does Paucitas give a legal opinion?
Paucitas does not give a legal opinion, but establishes the facts and tests the method. The legal judgment is for the court and the lawyers involved.
What does a counter-expertise cost?
Paucitas tailors every investigation. You receive a bespoke quote in advance, which we go through together, so there are no surprises. The intake is free.
From Amsterdam, for the whole of the UK
Everything can be done fully online. Prefer to meet in person? You are very welcome at our office in Amsterdam, by appointment.
Paucitas is an independent expert firm based in the Netherlands that, for clients across the UK, investigates investment fraud and crypto fraud, establishes the origin and legitimacy of crypto assets and prepares expert reports for legal proceedings and compliance.
Your own situation
If you are reading this, you probably have a question about your own situation. That is exactly what Paucitas does.
The first step is contact by phone. You can book that call by phone or through the contact form, so you do not have to wait. In the call we look together at what can factually be established in your case and what Paucitas can examine for you.