What does a crypto expert do in a court case?

← Blog overview

Simcha SchrijverDate: | Week 24 | Reading time: 7 minutes | Updated:
Author:  Simcha Schrijver

In short

A crypto expert in a court case explains to the judge, independently, what happened on the blockchain. They establish the transactions and interpret them technically, but the legal judgement stays with the court. Sometimes the findings support one party's account, sometimes they add nuance.

Paucitas is an independent expert firm in the Netherlands that prepares expert reports for legal proceedings, in hundreds of cases a year. Solicitors, insolvency practitioners and litigants instruct us when crypto plays a part in the case.

Get in touch with Paucitas or ring +31 20 244 5774. In a free intake you will hear what an independent report can add to your proceedings.

In a nutshell

A crypto expert turns blockchain data into facts a court can weigh. Paucitas does this independently, traceably and without a legal opinion, in civil, criminal and tax proceedings.

A bitcoin transfer between two former business partners. One calls it a loan, the other a gift. Both legal teams have a pile of screenshots, but nobody can explain to the judge what is actually on the blockchain. That is exactly when a crypto expert comes in.

This blog calmly explains what such an expert does, what they do not do, and why independence is everything.

What does a crypto expert do in a court case?

What does a crypto expert do in a court case? 5 tasks

In proceedings involving crypto, the court needs someone who understands the technology and can also explain it plainly. A crypto expert witness does five things at its core:

  • Sharpen the question: what exactly needs to be established, and what does not.
  • Establish the transactions: which addresses, which amounts, which dates.
  • Interpret the facts technically: does the pattern fit a one-off payment, or repayments?
  • Account for the method: so that someone else could repeat the work and reach the same facts.
  • State the limits: what the data cannot support is set out too.

Does crypto play a part in your case or a client's? Let Paucitas take a look, without obligation. You can ring at any time, 24/7, on +31 20 244 5774.

Can a crypto expert really give evidence in court?

Yes. In England and Wales, expert evidence in civil cases is governed by Part 35 of the Civil Procedure Rules. An expert's overriding duty is to the court, not to the party paying the fee. The court can also direct a single joint expert. Scottish courts likewise rely on independent expert evidence. More on that role is in independent expert.

What matters is that the expert stays within their field. They explain what can be seen on the blockchain. Whether something was a loan or a gift in law is for the judge.

Establishing or interpreting: where is the difference?

Establishing is the objective part. On a given date an amount went from address A to address B, the transaction was confirmed and the amount moved on afterwards. Those are facts anyone can check on the blockchain.

Interpreting is the explanatory part, strictly within the technology. Did payments flow back later? Does the pattern fit one transfer or a series? What the expert does not do is conclude that a loan agreement existed. That step stays with the court.

An example from practice

Two former partners were in dispute over a transfer of just over two bitcoin. One side spoke of a loan, the other of a gift.

Paucitas established when and from which address the bitcoin was sent, and followed the movements in the months after. Three smaller payments turned out to flow back to an address of the sender. The report set out those facts without a conclusion on loan or gift. The judge had a factual basis for their own decision.

Paucitas takes privacy very seriously and never shares clients' personal details. This is a composite example: names, amounts and details have been changed. The situation is one we see in practice.

In which proceedings does a crypto expert play a part?

In civil cases it is often about a disputed transfer, ownership of a wallet or the division of assets. In criminal cases about where money came from and where it went, for example where money laundering or fraud is suspected. In tax matters about whether the origin of assets can be substantiated.

The division is always the same: the expert establishes the technical facts, the legal or tax judgement lies with the competent party. Paucitas does not give tax advice. Are you a solicitor or insolvency practitioner? Then also read how Paucitas supports lawyers and insolvency practitioners.

What is in a good expert report?

A report for the court must be readable on its own, even without a technical background. It contains the question and the data provided, the relevant transactions with dates and amounts, an explanation in plain English, the method followed and a clear statement of what falls outside the investigation. What a court expects is covered in our blog on a blockchain report for court.

Why does independence carry so much weight?

A court gains little from a report that works towards an outcome. The value lies in neutrality: the same facts, whoever gave the instruction. Paucitas does all tracing itself, without tracing tools, and records every step. Where needed, we also go through documents, emails and other communication, so that a complete picture emerges, with a timeline and the route of the money, step by step. You receive a report that anyone can follow and understand step by step, including the other side.

Is there already a report from another party and do you doubt it? Paucitas reviews it independently in a counter-expertise or second opinion. Sometimes we endorse the conclusions, sometimes nuance is needed. You will hear it honestly.

Who can act as a crypto expert in a dispute?

Paucitas. We work for solicitors, insolvency practitioners, businesses and individuals in proceedings where crypto plays a part. Simcha Schrijver has more than ten years of experience in blockchain investigation. More on our role in proceedings is on the page expert report for court.

  • Costs: every investigation is tailored. You receive a bespoke quote in advance, which we go through together, so there are no surprises.
  • Turnaround: from the same day to around two weeks.
  • Contact: you can ring at any time, 24/7. We answer the form within 1 to 3 hours, and email within 24 hours, usually the same day.

Are proceedings under way or on the horizon? Get in touch for a no-obligation introduction, or ring +31 20 244 5774. The sooner the facts are clear, the calmer you go into the case.

Source: Civil Procedure Rules Part 35, justice.gov.uk.

Do you have questions about this blog?

Feel free to get in touch with Paucitas. Paucitas can be reached by phone 24/7, including evenings and weekends. Through the contact form we usually reply within 1 to 3 hours, and we answer e-mail within 24 hours.

Contact form

Usually a reply within 1 to 3 hours

"*" indicates required fields

This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

We only use your details to contact you about your request. You can read more in our privacy statement.

We only use your details to contact you about your request. You can read more about this in our privacy statement.

More short answers

Paucitas also answers frequently asked questions about crypto investigation briefly and clearly in the knowledge base.

Frequently asked questions about a crypto expert in a court case

What is a crypto expert witness?

Paucitas explains: an independent expert who explains to the court what blockchain data means. They establish facts and interpret them technically, without a legal opinion.

Can a crypto expert give evidence in a UK court?

Paucitas confirms that this is possible. In England and Wales, Part 35 of the Civil Procedure Rules sets out an expert's overriding duty to the court. Scottish courts also hear independent expert evidence. The court weighs the report alongside the other evidence.

Does the expert say who is right?

Paucitas does not give that view. The expert sets out the technical facts. Whether something was, for example, a loan or a gift is for the court to decide.

Can Paucitas review an existing report from another party?

Paucitas can do that. In a counter-expertise or second opinion Paucitas assesses the method and the conclusions. You hear where we agree and where nuance is needed.

How quickly can an expert report be ready?

Paucitas delivers the report between the same day and around two weeks, depending on the scope. You receive a bespoke quote in advance, which we go through together.

Independent expert firm

From Amsterdam, for the whole of the UK

Everything can be done fully online. Prefer to meet in person? You are very welcome at our office in Amsterdam, by appointment.

Paucitas is an independent expert firm based in the Netherlands that, for clients across the UK, investigates investment fraud and crypto fraud, establishes the origin and legitimacy of crypto assets and prepares expert reports for legal proceedings and compliance.

Your own situation

If you are reading this, you probably have a question about your own situation. That is exactly what Paucitas does.

The first step is contact by phone. You can book that call by phone or through the contact form, so you do not have to wait. In the call we look together at what can factually be established in your case and what Paucitas can examine for you.

Go to the contact form

Warning: Scammers are posing as Paucitas! Click here for more information

We are available 24/7 at: