My crypto history is not complete: what does CARF reporting to HMRC mean for me?
Author: Simcha Schrijver, independent expert
In short
Do you have an incomplete crypto history and wonder what the new reporting rules mean for you? An incomplete history is not a problem in itself. You do need to be able to explain any difference between what a provider reports about you and what you declare yourself.
Paucitas reconstructs crypto history transaction by transaction, even when a provider has disappeared. Turnaround is from the same day to around two weeks.
Get in touch with Paucitas and you will hear which part of your history can still be reconstructed.
In a nutshell
New reporting rules mean providers pass on user and transaction data, with the first UK reports due in 2027. Start the reconstruction before anyone asks: sources are still available now that may vanish later. Paucitas does that for you.
News about crypto data being shared with tax authorities often raises a practical question rather than a tax one: I have not kept everything, so what now? That is an understandable worry, and you are certainly not alone. What DAC8 means as an EU scheme is explained in the glossary. This blog is about the evidence side: how an incomplete history can be made as complete as possible.

What do crypto providers report under the new rules?
Under new UK rules, UK-based reporting cryptoasset service providers have to collect information about their users and their transactions and report it to HMRC. According to GOV.UK, the first reports are due between 1 January and 31 May 2027. In the EU, a similar scheme called DAC8 applies: EU countries exchange the data for 2026 by 30 September 2027.
What matters most is what is not in those reports. Transfers between your own wallets, purchases from a party that has since disappeared and swaps you made years ago outside a provider are not included. More on the scheme is in CARF and crypto reporting to HMRC.
What if you have an incomplete crypto history?
Then you need to be able to explain any difference, and an explanation without underlying transactions rarely holds up. A crypto history is not a file you download somewhere. It is a chain built from several sources, each covering part of the period. In practice the gaps are nearly always in three places:
- A provider that has gone: the platform no longer exists, and neither do your account and the export function.
- Your own wallets without notes: the transactions are still there, but not the reason or the value at the time.
- Swaps between coins: every swap has two sides, and those are rarely kept together.
Paucitas starts with the transactions that do still exist and works back from there. An address you can still point to yields a full history of that address, even if you kept nothing yourself.
Do you recognise one or more of these gaps? Let Paucitas take a look before anyone asks. You can always call, 24/7, on +31 20 244 5774.
What if your old provider no longer exists or you cannot get into a wallet?
Then Paucitas works with what is still visible from the outside: transactions to and from that provider's addresses, your bank entries from that period and any correspondence you still have. How that works is explained in reconstructing crypto history when the exchange has gone.
If you can no longer get into a wallet, Paucitas looks at whether getting back into your own wallet is technically possible, only for a wallet that is lawfully yours. Whether that works depends on what is left: a partial or full recovery phrase, a file or a note. We are honest about what is realistic in your situation. If there is nothing to go on, we say so.
Case: a history from 2016 with a provider that disappeared
A private individual bought crypto from 2016, first from a provider that later closed, then from two others. He had kept nothing from the early years. Using his bank entries and two old addresses he could still point to, the route could be followed from the very first purchase. One swap from that period stayed uncertain and went into the report as a stated limitation, with the reason given.
Names, amounts and details differ from reality; the situation is as we come across it in practice.
What does the Paucitas report give you?
You receive a chronological overview of your holdings and transactions per period, with the source for each part and a separate list of what cannot be established. Paucitas does all the tracing itself, without tracing tools, and checks every transaction individually. On top of that, Paucitas reads through all the relevant conversations, documents, emails and other communication, so you get a complete picture, with a timeline and where all the money came from and went, step by step. The result is a report that anyone can follow and understand step by step. What such an overview looks like is shown in getting crypto holdings in order for your tax return.
Paucitas does not give tax advice: we provide the evidence, and you or your adviser handle the tax return. Should HMRC ask a question later, the evidence is ready.
Every investigation is tailored: you receive a quote in advance that we go through together, with no surprises. What we do for private individuals is on the page for private individuals.
A file built in advance is shorter and stronger than the same file under time pressure. Get in touch with Paucitas and send an overview of the providers and addresses you remember, even if it is incomplete. You can always call, 24/7, on +31 20 244 5774. Via the form you will hear from us within 1 to 3 hours, and we answer emails within 24 hours, usually the same day.
Sources: GOV.UK, check if you will need to report cryptoasset data to HMRC.
See how Paucitas approaches this in practice on the page Getting your crypto in order for your tax return.
Do you have questions about this blog?
Feel free to get in touch with Paucitas. Paucitas can be reached by phone 24/7, including evenings and weekends. Through the contact form we usually reply within 1 to 3 hours, and we answer e-mail within 24 hours.
Contact form
Usually a reply within 1 to 3 hours
"*" indicates required fields
We only use your details to contact you about your request. You can read more about this in our privacy statement.
More short answers
Paucitas also answers frequently asked questions about crypto investigation briefly and clearly in the knowledge base.
Frequently asked questions about an incomplete crypto history
Can my crypto history be reconstructed if I kept nothing?
Paucitas can often reconstruct a large part of it. An address you can still point to yields its full history via the blockchain. Whatever does not add up is named as a limitation.
Do I have to be able to prove my crypto history?
Paucitas can reassure you: you do not need to keep every receipt. You do need to be able to explain a difference between your return and reported data with underlying transactions.
When will HMRC receive data about my crypto?
Paucitas points to GOV.UK: UK-based providers have to send their first reports to HMRC between 1 January and 31 May 2027.
Does Paucitas give tax advice?
Paucitas does not give tax advice. Paucitas provides the evidence, with the source for each part. You or your adviser handle the tax return.
How quickly can Paucitas help?
Paucitas completes an investigation within the same day to around two weeks. You can call 24/7, and via the form you will hear from us within 1 to 3 hours.
From Amsterdam, for the whole of the UK
Everything can be done fully online. Prefer to meet in person? You are very welcome at our office in Amsterdam, by appointment.
Paucitas is an independent expert firm based in the Netherlands that, for clients across the UK, investigates investment fraud and crypto fraud, establishes the origin and legitimacy of crypto assets and prepares expert reports for legal proceedings and compliance.
Your own situation
If you are reading this, you probably have a question about your own situation. That is exactly what Paucitas does.
The first step is contact by phone. You can book that call by phone or through the contact form, so you do not have to wait. In the call we look together at what can factually be established in your case and what Paucitas can examine for you.