Proving the origin of crypto assets: bank, HMRC, accountant and solicitor

In short

Proving the origin of crypto assets means showing, with documents, where your crypto came from, when you acquired it and which route it took. The question usually comes from HMRC or your bank, and your own overview is often not enough. Paucitas records the route in a report that anyone can follow step by step; ring us any time, day or night, or fill in the contact form for a free first conversation.

Updated:

Simcha Schrijver, PaucitasTyler Dijst, PaucitasPrefer to speak to someone straight away? Call 24/7+31 20 244 5774

What exactly does HMRC ask for when it checks your crypto?

Paucitas explains: when HMRC looks at crypto, it asks in practice for three things: which disposals you made, where the tokens came from, and how the gains or losses you reported were calculated. It does not only test the amount, but above all whether an outsider can work your tax return back to source data, step by step.

What the rules say

HMRC can ask for information and documents by written notice under Schedule 36 to the Finance Act 2008, where they are reasonably required to check your tax position. The notice sets the period within which you have to comply, and that period has to be reasonable. Not complying can lead to penalties.

Old years do not automatically fall outside the picture. HMRC’s normal time limit for an assessment is 4 years from the end of the tax year, extended to 6 years where a loss of tax was careless and 20 years where it was deliberate. The fact that an exchange no longer exists does not change what HMRC can ask for. The blockchain does remain available: transactions stay visible there, even years later.

HMRC’s guidance lists the records it expects, including the type of token, the date of each disposal, the number of tokens disposed of and left, the value in pounds sterling, bank statements and the pooled costs. Sources: HMRC Compliance Handbook, CH53100 and HMRC: check if you need to pay tax when you sell cryptoassets.

What proof of crypto holdings do banks and HMRC ask for?

No authority issues an official proof of crypto holdings in the way a bank issues a statement. What works in practice is a set of source data that confirm each other: the exchange statement, an overview of balances, the CSV export of transactions and the blockchain data in which those transactions can be found.

A Paucitas report adds the link you cannot supply yourself: a check that the source data match what is on the blockchain, and a chronological overview of the route. That is how our source of funds service works.

What records does HMRC expect?

Paucitas notes: HMRC expects a record of every transaction in pounds sterling, the pooled costs per type of token, and the underlying exports that make those figures traceable. A total alone is not enough; it has to be traceable per address and per token.

How to put the records together
  1. List all wallets and exchange accounts, including the ones you no longer use.
  2. Obtain the statement and the CSV export from each exchange for the tax year concerned, which runs from 6 April to 5 April.
  3. For each self-custodied wallet, make an export of the addresses and transactions, and of the balances on any date you are asked about.
  4. Convert each transaction and balance into pounds sterling at the rate at that moment and record which price source you used.

When is an exchange statement not enough?

As Paucitas puts it: an exchange records only what happens on that exchange. As soon as funds move outside it, the statement is incomplete. The missing link can be established on the blockchain, because transfers between wallets and exchanges are publicly verifiable.

Situations where the statement falls short
  • You held funds outside the exchange in your own wallet.
  • You used several exchanges and transferred between them.
  • The exchange no longer exists, or the statement misses one or more years.
  • You received crypto from someone else rather than buying it.
  • The funds came from mining, staking or a private transaction between individuals.

How do I prove origin without exchange history?

If the exchange history is missing, Paucitas moves the investigation to the blockchain itself. From it we can establish when funds came in, from what kind of service provider and how they moved afterwards. That gives a timeline and a route.

You also need your own documents that link that timeline to you: bank statements of payments to the exchange, old emails confirming an account, or a screenshot showing an address you can prove you control.

What does a bank ask for on a deposit from crypto?

Paucitas explains: on a deposit from crypto, a bank asks where the money came from and which route it took, because the bank itself is obliged to establish that origin. It is not a suspicion but a duty to check. All banks are bound by the same rules here.

What the bank usually wants to see

In practice, the bank asks for proof of purchase or deposit from pounds into crypto, a complete overview of the transactions in between, a balance on the date requested and an explanation of the difference between what you put in and the current value. A blocked account is rarely released on an explanation alone; the bank wants to check the underlying data. You never need to share keys or recovery phrases.

What does an accountant need, including for a company?

Paucitas notes: for the accounts, an accountant needs the balance per token at the balance sheet date, the valuation with the price source used, and evidence that the business actually controls those funds. A screenshot is not enough: it shows a balance, not control.

Separating business and personal holdings

For a company or its director, the evidence has three layers: which addresses belong to the company, which are personal, and which transactions took place between the two. That last layer is nearly always the problem, because transfers between personal and business funds were rarely recorded in the early years. The investigation reconstructs that separation from the transaction history and records, per address, on what basis it is attributed to the company or to the individual. The tax consequences are for your own adviser.

What do executors and solicitors ask for on a gift or an estate?

Where crypto forms part of a gift or an estate, the executor and the solicitor or accountant helping them need to know which holdings existed on the relevant date and who was able to dispose of them. With crypto that second point is rarely obvious, because holdings at an address are not held in anyone’s name.

What the investigation records for an estate
  • An overview of the holdings per wallet and per coin on the date of death or of the gift.
  • A valuation on that same date, with the price source and the moment used, because a crypto price moves within a single day.
  • Who was able to dispose of the holdings: on which addresses they were held, in a personal wallet or with an exchange, and what shows that the deceased or the donor had control.

Crypto counts towards the value of an estate for Inheritance Tax. In England and Wales the estate is valued before probate is applied for; in Scotland the executor lists the deceased’s property when applying for confirmation. Whether the holdings are still accessible also belongs in the investigation, not in an assumption. The conclusions are for the executor or your adviser; Paucitas gives no tax or legal advice.

What changes with the Cryptoasset Reporting Framework from 2026?

As Paucitas puts it: from 1 January 2026, UK cryptoasset service providers under the Cryptoasset Reporting Framework (CARF) have to check their customers and report their details and a summary of their transactions to HMRC every year. The tax rules do not change, but HMRC can now place your tax return alongside the provider’s data.

What this means for crypto in your own wallet

The first report covers 1 January to 31 December 2026 and has to be submitted between 1 January and 31 May 2027. What happens in a wallet you hold yourself is not reported by a provider. That is exactly where the difference arises that you have to be able to explain: HMRC sees what passes through the provider, not what happens outside it. If your return differs, questions follow, and they are best answered with a traceable account.

See HMRC’s guidance on reporting cryptoasset user and transaction data and the Cryptoassets Manual, CRYPTO49000.

What is in an origin report, what does it cost and how long does it take?

A Paucitas report follows a fixed structure, tailored to its purpose: bank, HMRC, accountant, executor or proceedings. An investigation takes from the same day to around two weeks, depending on size and urgency. Every investigation is tailored: you receive a bespoke quote in advance, which we go through with you, so there are no surprises.

The fixed structure of the report
  1. Background and description of the assignment
  2. Questions to be answered
  3. Scope of the investigation
  4. Assumptions
  5. Data supplied
  6. Sources consulted
  7. Method in outline
  8. Verification and quality assurance
  9. Reservations and limitations
  10. Findings per element
  11. Chronological overview
  12. Analysis and coherence
  13. Conclusion
  14. Declaration of independence
  15. Appendices

With an origin question, the declaration of independence often matters most. Paucitas does not act for an exchange, a supplier or a platform and has no interest in the outcome.

The investigation step by step
  1. Intake. You set out the question and the purpose. The purpose determines the scope. The intake is free.
  2. Data list. You receive a list of what is needed; you can supply it digitally or at our office.
  3. Analysis. The exports are placed alongside the blockchain data and traced transaction by transaction.
  4. Verification. Paucitas does all tracing itself, without tracing tools. Every transaction is verified individually before it goes into the report.
  5. Report and explanation. Delivery with the reservations clearly stated. Where needed, we explain the report to your adviser, accountant, solicitor or the authority.

What cannot be proven?

Whatever can no longer be reconstructed is stated explicitly in the report. A gap that has been named carries less weight for HMRC or a bank than one they discover themselves.

The limits at a glance
  • Transactions off the blockchain, such as cash payments or internal bookings within an exchange, can only be included where documents exist.
  • Where mixers or privacy-focused networks are used, the chain cannot always be followed in full; the report then states up to which point the route is established.
  • Paucitas gives no tax or legal advice and makes no commitment about the outcome.
  • Paucitas holds no funds and carries out no transactions on behalf of clients.

About the author

R.T. (Tyler) Dijst is director and co-founder of Paucitas and runs its operations. He oversees the quality and consistency of case handling and is involved in the expert phase of complex cases. His work focuses on complex blockchain investigation: tracing intricate transaction flows, analysing wallets and mapping how funds are routed across the chain. He also assesses whether crypto coins are genuine and recognises counterfeit or imitation coins.

What can you do now?

Paucitas knows that a question about the origin of your crypto can feel stressful, especially if your account is blocked or a deadline is running. Do get in touch. We first look with you at what you still have and tell you honestly what can be established. One export, address or bank statement is enough to start.

Ring us any time, day or night, on +31 20 244 5774, or fill in the contact form; you will hear from us within 1 to 3 hours. If you prefer to email, we reply within 24 hours, usually the same day.

Do you have a question about your own situation?

Feel free to get in touch with Paucitas. Paucitas can be reached by phone 24/7, including evenings and weekends. Through the contact form we usually reply within 1 to 3 hours, and we answer e-mail within 24 hours.

Contact form

Usually a reply within 1 to 3 hours

"*" indicates required fields

This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

We only use your details to contact you about your request. You can read more in our privacy statement.

We only use your details to contact you about your request. You can read more about this in our privacy statement.

Frequently asked questions

Short answers to the questions we are asked most often.

Why is my bank asking where my crypto came from?

Paucitas explains: the bank itself is obliged to establish the origin of incoming money. What the bank needs is a route it can follow, from purchase to payout.

HMRC is asking for evidence of my crypto, who can provide it?

Paucitas maps your crypto holdings and reconstructs their origin on the blockchain, recorded in a report HMRC can check. You or your tax adviser use that report in your reply; Paucitas does not give tax advice itself.

What if I cannot prove the origin?

Paucitas then records in the report up to which point the route is established and where the evidence stops. That is useful too: it makes the gap explicit, which is easier for HMRC or a bank to deal with than an incomplete overview without explanation.

I have to show my crypto profit was earned honestly. Where do I start?

Paucitas advises: start at the beginning: which pounds were paid in, when and from which account. The chain is then built forward, address by address and exchange by exchange, up to today’s balance or payout.

What if I have hundreds of addresses and tens of thousands of transactions?

Paucitas does not see that as an obstacle. Large numbers are ordered per network and per period; only the items that matter for the question are worked out in detail. The report states which parts have been fully reconstructed.

Independent expert firm

From Amsterdam, for the whole of the UK

Everything can be done fully online. Prefer to meet in person? You are very welcome at our office in Amsterdam, by appointment.

Paucitas is an independent expert firm based in the Netherlands that, for clients across the UK, investigates investment fraud and crypto fraud, establishes the origin and legitimacy of crypto assets and prepares expert reports for legal proceedings and compliance.

Your own situation

If you are reading this, you probably have a question about your own situation. That is exactly what Paucitas does.

The first step is contact by phone. You can book that call by phone or through the contact form, so you do not have to wait. In the call we look together at what can factually be established in your case and what Paucitas can examine for you.

Go to the contact form

Warning: Scammers are posing as Paucitas! Click here for more information

We are available 24/7 at: