What do I as a lawyer have to supply so that a crypto investigation becomes usable in my case?

← Blog overview

Simcha Schrijver, independent expertDate: | Week: 37 | Reading time: 7 minutes | Updated:
Author: Simcha Schrijver, independent expert

In short

Instructing a crypto investigation works in your case when five things are fixed in advance: the questions, the scope, the assumptions, the reference date and the form of the report. On top of that, the expert needs four kinds of documents from your client. Exactly which ones differs from case to case.

Paucitas works as an independent expert firm for solicitors, barristers and insolvency practitioners and prepares expert reports for legal proceedings, with a turnaround from the same day to around two weeks.

Get in touch with Paucitas and we will help you frame the questions, without obligation.

In a nutshell

Whether a report holds up later is decided at the instruction stage, not on delivery. Paucitas helps you frame the questions so that the answer is one you can use in the proceedings.

You have a crypto element in a file for the first time. The question then is not whether you need an expert, but what you give that expert to work with. That is where the report stands or falls, and where you as the lawyer have most influence. What an expert report is and how it differs from a party memo is explained in the glossary.

What do I as a lawyer have to supply so that a crypto investigation becomes usable in my case?

What belongs in the instruction for a crypto investigation?

Five elements belong in the instruction. Paucitas records them with you in writing before the start, because together they determine what can later appear in the report.

  • Questions: questions that lead to a finding of fact, not an opinion.
  • Scope: the period, the addresses and accounts included, and what is left out.
  • Assumptions: which documents are taken as given and which are to be tested.
  • Reference date: the moment to which the position is described.
  • Form: whether it is for court, the language, and whether a statement of independence is needed.

The most common mistake is asking about people rather than transactions. A blockchain records addresses and amounts, not names. A question about the route and end point of the funds does produce a usable answer. Paucitas is happy to discuss with you how to frame the question most sharply before anything is fixed.

Examples of weak and better questions

Weak: "Was my client scammed?" Better: "Which route did my client's payments follow in a given period, and at which service provider did they arrive?" Weak: "Is this wealth legitimate?" Better: "Does the route from first purchase to sale match the bank transactions in time and amount?"

Which documents does your client provide?

As a rule your client provides four kinds of documents: a list of wallets and accounts with the network for each address, the transaction details for each payment, account details and correspondence with providers, and documents outside the blockchain, such as agreements and bank statements. If one is missing, the turnaround can increase considerably.

If the other side works with a cryptoasset business, you can check the FCA Warning List and the FCA's information on the cryptoasset AML regime. Documents can be supplied digitally or at our office. Each case gets a document checklist, and where needed Paucitas helps gather them. Paucitas never asks for a recovery phrase or private key.

Want to know what is still missing from your file? Send Paucitas your draft questions. You can always ring us, 24/7, on +31 20 244 5774.

How do you stop the report being unusable in proceedings?

A report is rarely challenged on its outcome, but often on whether the route to that outcome can be followed. Paucitas does all tracing itself, without tracing tools, and checks every transaction individually before it goes into the report. On top of that, Paucitas reads through all the relevant conversations, documents, emails and other communication, so you get a complete picture, with a timeline and where all the money came from and went, step by step. In proceedings that is an advantage: every step can be questioned on its own. The result is a report that anyone can follow and understand step by step.

Simcha Schrijver has delivered an accredited course on cryptocurrency, blockchain and wallets for criminal defence lawyers in the Netherlands. That experience shapes the way we set up the instruction with you.

What a court expects of the report itself is covered in requirements for a blockchain report in court, and the questions you can expect at a hearing in blockchain evidence: questions from the judge. In England and Wales, Part 35 of the Civil Procedure Rules governs expert evidence in civil cases.

Case: three addresses supplied, seven found

A solicitor had clear questions, but the client's list of addresses was incomplete: three addresses had been supplied and there turned out to be seven. Because Paucitas spotted this in the first phase and adjusted the scope with the solicitor, the report still matched the question at issue in the proceedings.

Names, amounts and details differ from reality; the situation is as we come across it in practice.

What can a crypto investigation establish, and what not?

An investigation establishes the route and end point of funds. Where the chain enters a service provider, Paucitas records it, so that customer data can be requested through the proper channels. Set that limit in the instruction, not only in the report. Then your client's expectations and the content of the report match.

Is there already a report from the other side? Paucitas can review that too; read more about expert review in a crypto dispute.

What do you get, how long does it take and what does it cost?

You receive a report that can be used in court, with a statement of independence and a chronological overview in which every transaction can be checked individually. An investigation takes from the same day to around two weeks. Every investigation is tailored: you receive a bespoke quote in advance that we go through together, with no surprises.

How a report is introduced in proceedings is covered in a crypto report for legal proceedings. More on the role of the investigator is in the independent expert in legal proceedings, and what working together means in practice is on the page for lawyers and insolvency practitioners.

Facing a case with a crypto element? Get in touch with Paucitas for a short initial call. You can always ring us, 24/7, on +31 20 244 5774. Through the form you will hear from us within 1 to 3 hours, and we answer emails within 24 hours, usually the same day.

Sources: Civil Procedure Rules, Part 35; FCA, Warning List; FCA, cryptoasset AML regime.

Do you have questions about this blog?

Feel free to get in touch with Paucitas. Paucitas can be reached by phone 24/7, including evenings and weekends. Through the contact form we usually reply within 1 to 3 hours, and we answer e-mail within 24 hours.

Contact form

Usually a reply within 1 to 3 hours

"*" indicates required fields

This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

We only use your details to contact you about your request. You can read more in our privacy statement.

We only use your details to contact you about your request. You can read more about this in our privacy statement.

More short answers

Paucitas also answers frequently asked questions about crypto investigation briefly and clearly in the knowledge base.

Frequently asked questions about instructing a crypto investigation

Who prepares a crypto report for legal proceedings?

Paucitas recommends an independent expert who establishes the route of the funds personally and checks every transaction. Paucitas provides such reports for lawyers and insolvency practitioners, with a statement of independence.

Which documents does the expert need from my client?

Paucitas as a rule asks for a list of wallets and accounts, the transaction details, correspondence with providers and documents outside the blockchain. Each case gets a checklist.

Can an investigation establish who owns an address?

Paucitas explains: a blockchain does not record names. Paucitas does establish at which provider funds arrived, so that the details can be requested through the proper channels.

Can Paucitas review the other side's report?

Paucitas can do that, yes. That is an expert review: the report is checked step by step on the route, the links and the caveats.

How quickly can Paucitas start?

Paucitas starts after a short initial call and agreement on the bespoke quote. The turnaround is from the same day to around two weeks.

Independent expert firm

From Amsterdam, for the whole of the UK

Everything can be done fully online. Prefer to meet in person? You are very welcome at our office in Amsterdam, by appointment.

Paucitas is an independent expert firm based in the Netherlands that, for clients across the UK, investigates investment fraud and crypto fraud, establishes the origin and legitimacy of crypto assets and prepares expert reports for legal proceedings and compliance.

Your own situation

If you are reading this, you probably have a question about your own situation. That is exactly what Paucitas does.

The first step is contact by phone. You can book that call by phone or through the contact form, so you do not have to wait. In the call we look together at what can factually be established in your case and what Paucitas can examine for you.

Go to the contact form

Warning: Scammers are posing as Paucitas! Click here for more information

We are available 24/7 at: