Blockchain investigation explained: method, verification and evidential value
In short
Blockchain investigation is establishing, and recording in a traceable way, what has happened to crypto: which transactions, when, between which addresses, and up to which point the route can be established. It delivers no opinion, but a reconstruction anyone can follow step by step; sometimes far, sometimes to a clear end point. Paucitas does this work daily, without tracing tools, so ring us any time or ask for a free intake.
Updated:
Paucitas: evidential value does not come from a confident conclusion, but from every step being checkable.
What is blockchain investigation?
Paucitas explains: a blockchain is a public ledger in which transactions are recorded in sequence and can no longer be altered. Blockchain investigation uses that ledger as its source: it follows the movements of digital assets between addresses and connects them to what is known outside the ledger, such as exchange exports, bank statements and correspondence. The outcome is a reconstruction with a reference to the underlying transaction at every step.
The difference between a query and an investigation
An automated overview shows that two addresses are connected; an investigation explains why that connection is relevant, which assumptions sit beneath it and where the certainty stops. For a judge, a bank or HMRC, that last question is often more important than the first.
Further reading: blockchain, blockchain analysis and on-chain.
What can and cannot be seen on a public blockchain?
Paucitas notes: visible are the sending and receiving address, the amount, the time, the token and the transaction hash by which anyone can check the transaction. The full history of an address is visible too, including transactions from years back. Not visible is who controls an address: an address is a string of characters without a name.
What falls outside the blockchain
Also not visible are bookings within an exchange’s own administration and payments made off-chain, such as cash transfers. That does not mean those steps stay unknown: they can only be established with the documents of the parties involved alongside.
See also: transaction hash, wallet and exchange.
How does a blockchain investigation proceed methodically?
An investigation starts from a fixed point: a transaction, an address or an export whose provenance is certain. From there the work runs in both directions: forwards to see where the assets went, backwards to see where they came from. Every step is recorded separately. This approach forms the core of the blockchain research that Paucitas offers as a service.
Patterns that set the direction
Along the way, patterns appear that prove nothing in themselves but do determine the direction: an amount split across many addresses, conversion into a stablecoin to remove price movement, a hop to another blockchain, or consolidation at an address belonging to a service provider. The report states such patterns as observations, not as inferences.
Further reading: chain reconstruction, peel chain, cross-chain and mixer.
Why does Paucitas do all tracing itself, without tracing tools?
Paucitas does all tracing itself, without tracing tools. Every transaction and every transaction hash is verified individually before it goes into a report. That is a deliberate choice.
Why an automated flag is not proof
An automated flag is an assumption made by the vendor, and in proceedings that assumption cannot be tested if nobody can explain it. Paucitas’s findings can be tested: they rest on publicly accessible sources and can therefore be checked and confirmed by anyone, without access to our working environment.
See also the blog manual blockchain investigation versus automated tools.
How is a finding verified?
For Paucitas, verification means that a finding is established a second way before it goes into the report. A transaction is checked in more than one source, a time is placed alongside the client’s own records, and an amount is traced back to the original unit rather than to a converted value.
How the report accounts for this
The report contains a separate part on verification and quality assurance, setting out which checks were carried out, and a part on reservations and limitations, setting out what was not checked and why. Together those two parts determine how much weight a reader can give to the findings.
See also: crypto investigation report.
What determines the evidential value of a blockchain report?
As Paucitas puts it: evidential value comes from traceability. A report that gives the transaction hash at every step can be checked by the other side. A report containing only a final figure and a screenshot cannot, and in proceedings it loses its value for that reason.
Three points that weigh heavily
- Is the investigator independent of the parties?
- Can the data be traced back to a source the reader can consult?
- Does the report state explicitly where the certainty stops?
A report that is open on all three points holds up better than one that sounds stronger. Where a report already exists and is disputed, a counter-expertise or second opinion is the appropriate route. Where the case goes to a hearing, read about the expert report for court.
Further reading: evidential value, the blog a blockchain report that holds up in court and what a crypto expert does in a court case.
What does independence mean in a technical investigation?
Independence means something concrete here: no instructions from an exchange or platform, no fee that depends on the outcome, and no interest in the conclusion. Paucitas never works for a percentage of an amount recovered, because that creates exactly the interest that makes a report worthless.
How that is recorded
The report contains a separate part in which that position is recorded; for a bank, HMRC or a judge it is often the first thing checked. Paucitas is also non-custodial, holds no client funds and carries out no transactions on their behalf, and is therefore not a cryptoasset exchange provider or custodian wallet provider within the meaning of the Money Laundering Regulations 2017.
See also: independent expert, expert witness and the blog acting as an independent expert.
Which data is needed, and what if the wallet is inaccessible?
An investigation starts from a single starting point: a transaction, an address, a screenshot of a wallet or the communication you had with a party. Even without complete records, more can usually be established than people expect. If the wallet is no longer accessible, that changes the scope but not the possibility: what was sent and received remains visible on the blockchain.
What else helps
- addresses and transaction hashes;
- exports from the wallet app or from the exchanges where you hold an account;
- bank statements for the period concerned;
- correspondence, messages and screenshots.
After a first conversation you receive a list tailored to your situation. Data can be supplied at our office or digitally. Paucitas never asks of its own accord for your recovery phrase or private key. If you need help reading out or restoring your own wallet, we will guide you through it without needing to see that data ourselves. The report states to what extent access still exists, because that determines which next steps are realistic.
Further reading: private key, seed phrase and hardware wallet.
What is in an investigation report, how does it work and how long does it take?
A Paucitas report follows a fixed structure, tailored to its purpose. An investigation takes from the same day to about two weeks, depending on the case. Every investigation is tailored: you receive a bespoke quote in advance, which we go through with you, so there are no surprises; no work starts before the costs have been discussed and agreed.
The standard structure of the report
- Background and description of the assignment
- Questions to be answered
- Scope of the investigation
- Assumptions
- Data supplied
- Sources consulted
- Method in outline
- Verification and quality assurance
- Reservations and limitations
- Findings per element
- Chronological overview
- Analysis and coherence
- Conclusion
- Declaration of independence
- Appendices
The declaration of independence is the part a report is tested against first in proceedings. The method is deliberately kept in outline: it is accounted for without the report becoming a manual.
The investigation, step by step
- Intake. The question is sharpened and it is established which outcome is realistic. The intake is free.
- List of data required. You receive an overview of the data needed.
- Scope. Which addresses, which period and which blockchains fall within the investigation, and which do not.
- Reconstruction. The transactions are followed step by step and recorded with hash, time and amount.
- Reconciliation with the documents. On-chain data is placed alongside exports, statements and correspondence.
- Verification. Findings are checked against a second source or method.
- Report. Delivery according to the fixed structure, with the limitations stated explicitly.
- Explanation and follow-up. Where needed, we explain the report to your solicitor, accountant, the court or the authority handling the matter. If new data becomes available later, the report can be supplemented.
Further reading: the blogs how a blockchain transaction is investigated and frequently asked questions about blockchain investigation and aftercare.
In which situations is blockchain investigation used?
Paucitas explains: the method is the same; the question differs. Where fraud is suspected, it is about the route the money took. Where a substantiation is needed for a bank or HMRC, it is about the origin of a holding. In a division of assets or an insolvency, it is about which assets existed on a reference date. In a dispute about an existing report, it is about whether that report holds up.
See also: crypto fraud investigation, proving the origin of assets and crypto in divorce and legal matters.
What can blockchain investigation not do?
What an investigation cannot do determines the value of what it can. Paucitas does not itself establish who controls a crypto address, makes no commitment about the outcome and does not promise that money will come back. What is recorded is which service provider the funds went to, so that authorities can follow that up through the proper channels.
The limits at a glance
- Paucitas holds no funds itself and carries out no transactions on behalf of clients.
- A report confines itself to factual observations and the investigation of them.
- Off-chain transactions, such as cash payments or internal bookings within an exchange, are only included where underlying documents are available.
- Where mixers or privacy-focused networks are used, the chain cannot always be followed in full; the report then states up to which point the route can be established.
- Paucitas gives no tax or legal advice.
About the author
R.T. (Tyler) Dijst is director and co-founder of Paucitas and runs the operation. He safeguards the quality and consistency of case handling and is involved in the expert stage of complex matters. His work focuses on complex blockchain investigation: tracing intricate transaction flows, analysing wallets and mapping how funds are routed across the chain. He also assesses the authenticity of physical crypto coins and identifies counterfeit or imitation specimens.
What can you do now?
Would you like to know what Paucitas can establish on the blockchain in your situation? Do get in touch. One transaction, address or screenshot is enough to start; we will tell you honestly what is and is not possible.
Ring us any time, day or night, on +31 20 244 5774, fill in the contact form (you will hear from us within 1 to 3 hours) or email us (we reply within 24 hours, usually the same day). The intake is free and without obligation, and you receive a bespoke quote in advance.
Which pages belong to this topic?
- Blockchain: the ledger the investigation is based on.
- Chain reconstruction: recording the route step by step.
- Mixer: where certainty in the chain decreases.
- Evidential value: why traceability weighs more heavily than the conclusion.
- The full glossary: including the transaction hash and the crypto investigation report.
- Counter-expertise and second opinion: where a report already exists and is disputed.
- Expert report for court: where the case file goes to a hearing.
- Crypto fraud investigation: where fraud is suspected.
- Proving the origin of assets: for a substantiation to a bank, HMRC or an accountant.
- Crypto in divorce and legal matters: in a division of assets or an estate.
Short answers to specific questions
Short answers to individual questions are in the overview of questions and answers.
Background reading from the blog
Further reading in the knowledge base
Do you have a question about your own situation?
Feel free to get in touch with Paucitas. Paucitas can be reached by phone 24/7, including evenings and weekends. Through the contact form we usually reply within 1 to 3 hours, and we answer e-mail within 24 hours.
Contact form
Usually a reply within 1 to 3 hours
"*" indicates required fields
We only use your details to contact you about your request. You can read more about this in our privacy statement.
Frequently asked questions
Short answers to the questions we are asked most often.
Can every crypto trail be followed?
Paucitas: no. On a public blockchain the chain can in principle be followed, but where mixers or privacy-focused networks are used the certainty stops at a certain point. The report then states explicitly up to where the route can be established.
Does blockchain investigation establish who controls an address?
Paucitas: no. We record which service provider the funds went to, so that the information can be requested through the proper channels. Who controls an address is not something Paucitas establishes itself.
Does Paucitas need my private key or seed phrase?
Paucitas: no. We never ask of our own accord for your recovery phrase or private key. For the investigation, addresses, transactions and exports are sufficient.
How long does a blockchain investigation take?
Paucitas works with a turnaround of the same day to about two weeks, depending on the case.
What is the difference between blockchain analysis and a blockchain investigation?
Paucitas explains: analysis means organising transaction data. An investigation adds accountability to that: which source, which assumption, which check and which limitation. Paucitas does all tracing itself, without tracing tools, and verifies every transaction individually.
Can an old case still be investigated?
Paucitas: yes. Transactions remain visible, even years later. What changes is the chance that a balance is still held somewhere and that a service provider still holds data.
From Amsterdam, for the whole of the UK
Everything can be done fully online. Prefer to meet in person? You are very welcome at our office in Amsterdam, by appointment.
Paucitas is an independent expert firm based in the Netherlands that, for clients across the UK, investigates investment fraud and crypto fraud, establishes the origin and legitimacy of crypto assets and prepares expert reports for legal proceedings and compliance.
Your own situation
If you are reading this, you probably have a question about your own situation. That is exactly what Paucitas does.
The first step is contact by phone. You can book that call by phone or through the contact form, so you do not have to wait. In the call we look together at what can factually be established in your case and what Paucitas can examine for you.